⇤

Title

Menu
0
    0

    Your Cart is Empty

    Our #1 Goal: FLAVOR

    Our growing selection of hot sauces has been purpose built to compliment our world-known seasoning blends. Made in the USA from all-natural ingredients and paired with an unconditional freshness and flavor promise... Either you love it or you get your cash back.

    "VIOLENT HIPPIE" TOASTED COCONUT GHOST CHILE HOT SAUCE

    "THE BOWSE" CHIPOTLE PALE ALE HOT SAUCE

    OUR SAUCES ARE:

    ◆ Gluten Free / Non-GMO
    ◆ All Natural
    ◆ Free of Additives or Fillers
    ◆ Made in the USA
    ◆ Guaranteed Tasty AF

    SAVE WITH BUNDLES // BUILD YOUR OWN 5 PACK >>

  • Our #1 Goal: FLAVOR

    Our growing selection of hot sauces has been purpose built to compliment our world-known seasoning blends. Made in the USA from all-natural ingredients and paired with an unconditional freshness and flavor promise... Either you love it or you get your cash back.

  • "VIOLENT HIPPIE" TOASTED COCONUT GHOST CHILE HOT SAUCE

  • "THE BOWSE" CHIPOTLE PALE ALE HOT SAUCE

  • OUR SAUCES ARE:

    ◆ Gluten Free / Non-GMO
    ◆ All Natural
    ◆ Free of Additives or Fillers
    ◆ Made in the USA
    ◆ Guaranteed Tasty AF

  • SAVE WITH BUNDLES // BUILD YOUR OWN 5 PACK >>

  • PIE SLAYER
    PIE SLAYER
    PIE SLAYER
    PIE SLAYER
    PIE SLAYER
    PIE SLAYER
    PIE SLAYER
    PIE SLAYER

    PIE SLAYER

    $ 11.00
    Pie Slayer Pizza Sauce Product Identifier
    Real Sauce...

    Made with real stuff like tomatoes. honey, & butter with fresh spices like oregano, parsley, & basil.

    🍕 100% Fresh & Authentic

    AS REAL AS IT GETS...

    PIE SLAYER Pizza Sauce is your backyard pizzeria in a jar.

    This is that thick, rich, real tomato-forward punch your pies have been begging for... loaded with herbs, garlic, and that slow-simmered depth that sticks to your soul.

    No weak, watery nonsense. No plastic squeeze-top shortcut. This one’s authentic, clean, and handcrafted to bring your pizza game from frozen box to wood-fired legend.

    🍕 PERFECT FOR Homemade Pizza, Cast Iron Pies, & Dippin’ the Crust

    BUILT FOR YOUR BACKYARD

    No mystery ingredients. No pizza chain shortcuts. Just a handcrafted red sauce built for real-deal homemade pies. Thick, hearty, and loaded with crushed tomato flavor, PIE SLAYER hits with fresh herbs, garlic, and the real, authentic flavor you'll dream about.

    Whether you’re slinging cast iron pizzas, backyard ‘za on the grill, or dipping crust straight from the jar... this is the sauce your slice deserves.

    ⚡ Made proudly in ROCHESTER, NY USA

    FRESH BREWED & BOTTLED

    Tacticalories makes small-batch seasonings and sauces designed for people who care about real food and good times around the grill. Every bottle is handcrafted in the USAusing high-quality ingredients, with no fillers or shortcuts.

    This isn’t some cheap supermarket sugar-bomb. Our blends are built to elevate backyard cooking, whether you're feeding your family or the whole neighborhood. With rich, unique flavors and a loyal following, Tacticalories products turn every meal into something worth sharing.

    ⚡Certified Tasty AF

    PIE SLAYER Air Fryer Fried Ravioli READ RECIPE >
    PIE SLAYER Air Fryer Pizza Logs READ RECIPE >
    PIE SLAYER Pizza Dough Recipe READ RECIPE >

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 28 reviews
    86%
    (24)
    0%
    (0)
    0%
    (0)
    7%
    (2)
    7%
    (2)
    88.9
    100.0
    L
    Luke Nelson
    Pies have been SLAYYYYED!

    Behold, have murdered the horrendous behemoth that is Prego and found our new, favorite pizza sauce! If you don’t like this you shall be led to the gallows for your treasonous ways. Now we just need tactical ties to make the Witches (Italian) Herbs and seasoning law to accompany our delicious pie. The savory flavor is balanced well by the honey from killer bees…only the best for pie slaying.

    Thanks for making many great products, including this Pie Slayer. It is a hit among my family and friends with the right balance of savory and sweet. Buy this sauce!! P.S. Bring back Apple Sinnamon!

    R
    Rick Powell
    Pie Slayer Pizza Sauce

    It's the best pizza sauce I've ever tasted!

    T
    Trey Harris
    Card difficulty

    I have tried to order from your site numerous times and keep getting an error message saying that my card could not be added. My card is in good standing, I use it everyday.

    S
    Steve Lively
    Great Sauce

    I don't usually use a lot of pizza sauce, so I was skeptical, however, this a very good sauce. To me it tastes tangy and has a good tomato taste.

    B
    BN
    Love this sauce

    Hands down the best pizza sauce around. I bought six just this week to stock up.

    123

    FRESH BATCHES: